C. GODFEY GUNTHER
NYC Jails Governor &
Civil War Mayor ©
Chapter 4 of 7
New York, _____, 186__
Unofficial and private
To His Excellency, Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States:
It is stated in the newspapers that the United States has entertained
with favor the application made by the Commission of Exchanges for leave
to provide with blankets the prisoners of war confined to Elmira and
It is further stated that in order to accelerate action so as to give
this relief to perishing thousands before the severity of our climate
shall have destroyed them, permission was solicited for the
transportation of a cargo of cotton to this city, here to be converted
to the purpose by late.
A number of citizens, impelled by motives of humanity, have observed
with pain and anxiety that at this point the negotiation pauses. Each
chilly night increases the anxiety; the thought that poor men are
perishing from the cold cannot be thrust away; it will intrude.
These citizens have pressed me to head an appeal to your Excellency
to act, and to act favorably to this measure.
It has appeared to me that if this act of charity and humanity is to
be performed, it had best be the spontaneous act of the Executive on his
own motion and from the promptings of his own benevolence. In this view
of the matter, I have declined to concur in any public application to
you, whilst I can suppose it to be unnecessary.
Merely for my personal direction I solicit the favor of information
of whether your Excellency intends to comply with the request in
I beg an early reply.
Your Obt. Servant,
C. Godfrey Gunther
Mayor Gunther wrote
to Lincoln about
Elmira POWs' plight.
Today the graves of
3,000 of them
abut a state prison.
Among the minor mysteries in Lincoln's presidential papers is a
handwritten letter from C. Godfrey Gunther on mayoral stationery but labeled
"Unofficial and private." Undated by Gunther, the letter carries a notation
apparently added by some archivist along the way: "1864?"
The communication concerned getting blankets to prisoners of war in the
Finger Lakes city of Elmira before the harsh upstate winter gripped the camp
that had received its first Confederate POWs in the summer of 1864.
Gunther wrote that a group of citizen "impelled by motives of humanity"
had asked him to head a public appeal to Lincoln to allow a cargo of cotton
from the South to enter New York City where the blankets would be made and
shipped to Elmira. But the mayor explained he declined to head the open
petition drive because he viewed any such "public application . . . to be
|"if this act of charity and humanity is to be
performed, it had best be the spontaneous act of the Executive on his
own motion and from the promptings of his own benevolence."
An historical memorial marking the Elmira POW camp site in upstate
NY includes United States and Confederate States flags as well as
photo-illustrated text. The latter explains, among other things, how
runaway slave John W. Jones handled the burials with great care, respect
and meticulous record keeping. A plaque in his honor marks an entrance
to the Confederate section of Woodlawn National Cemetery.
The letter concludes by asking the President to let the mayor know
("merely for my personal direction") if Lincoln intended to grant the
An intriguing question arises relative to the timing of the letter and
its seeming effort to be "unofficial and private."
If written prior to Election Day, Nov. 8, 1964, was it a sincere attempt
by Gunther to remove the blanket project from the realm of Presidential
Or was it a ploy to have Lincoln make known his intent early enough, one
way or the other, so that Peace Democrats promoting the blanket project
could take credit for initiating it or, alternately, attack the President
for thwarting it?
If written after Lincoln had won re-election, did its "unofficial and
private" guise provide a mechanism for the Peace Democrat mayor to support
the blanket project without appearing to beg a kindness from a President
whom some of Gunther's supporters regarded as a mongrelizer and tyrant?
From the Confederate section of Woodlawn National Cemetery, where
nearly 3,000 Elmira POWs are buried, can been seen in the distance the
huge Elmira Correctional Facility, including one of its guard towers.
The answers to questions raised by the existence of the undated
"unofficial and private" letter from Gunther to Lincoln about the Elmira
POWs blanket project may never be known.
But the devastating toll exacted on the prisoners by the camp's inhumane
conditions is known. Lonnie R. Speer, in his
Portals to Hell: Military Prisons of the Civil War excerpted
extensively elsewhere on this NYCHS web site, notes that, unlike the other
POW facilities around the country up to that time, it didn't start out as a
fairly acceptable place of confinement and then slowly degenerate into a
concentration camp; Elmira Prison was one from the very day it began. In the
13 months that the camp operated, nearly 3,000 Confederates died there.
They are buried in a special section of Elmira's Woodlawn National
Cemetery where Unionist dead also are buried. So are other Americans who
fought in later wars involving United States forces. The cemetery is
situated next to the grounds of Elmira Correctional Facility, a New York
State Department of Correctional Services prison.
John W. Jones, the runaway slave whose caring burials of Elmira POWs
has helped so many Southern families trace and visit a fallen
Confederate relative's grave.
John W. Jones, retained to handle the Elmira POW burials, had been the
sexton of the Baptist Church in Elmira for decades. John, with his brothers
Charles and George, escaped from Southern slavery in 1843 and came to Elmira
from Leesburg, Va., after walking the hundreds of miles in 14 days, except
eight miles when they got a ride from a farmer.
Many a Southern family searching for the grave of a fallen Confederate
relative has been grateful for the extraordinary care, respect and
record-keeping diligence with which Jones went about his burial duties.
Because of his faithful service, they have been able to track down and visit
their kin's grave.
The approximately 3,000 Confederate POW burials in Woodlawn were
performed without benefit of services or ceremonies of any kind, quite
unlike what was accorded one Union casualty throughout New York and other
Northern states: Abraham Lincoln, whose funeral occasioned such public
mourning as never seen before and rarely since.
*Copyright on text. © 2001 by the New York Correction History Society
and Thomas C. McCarthy. Noncommercial use of text permitted with citation of
the society and/or its web site www.correctionhistory.org.