CHAPTER III.

NEBRASKA IN THE UNITED STATES SENATE,

PRELIMINARY HISTORICAL SKETCH.

   The territory of Nebraska was organized by act of congress May 30, 1854.
   January 11, 1860, Nebraska passed an act to submit the question of calling a state constitutional convention which was defeated at an election March 5, 1860.
   April 19, 1864, congress passed an act to enable Nebraska to submit a constitution to a vote of the people, with reference to admission. as a state of the Union, and the legislature framed and submitted such an instrument, which was adopted at an election June 2, 1866. Thereupon a bill for her admission passed congress July 27, 1866, which was held by President Johnson and neither signed nor returned during the session. January 16, 1867, another bill passed and was vetoed by the president and passed over his veto on the 9th day of February, 1867.
   The state constitution thus placed before congress provided for the exercise of suffrage by white male citizens only, but since emancipation had taken place and the 15th amendment was in process of adoption, an injunction was placed upon us, requiring that before admission the state legislature should agree, in behalf of the people, "that there shall be no denial of the elective franchise to any person, by reason of race or color," in the State of Nebraska. To secure this pledge, Governor Saunders convened the territorial legislature on the 20th day of February, 1867, when the fundamental condition was adopted, and President Johnson issued a proclamation March 1, 1867, declaring Nebraska a state in the Union.
   There being but four days of the second session of the thirty

(211)

212

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

ninth congress remaining, the Hon. T. M. Marquett, having been elected as member of the expiring congress, took the oath of office as the first member of congress for the new state. Three days thereafter, on March 4, 1867, began the session of the fortieth congress, with Gen. J. M. Thayer and T. W. Tipton as senators, and the Hon. John Taffe member of the house of representatives.
   The following extract from the senate journal explains itself:

   MR. TRUMBULL: I have the pleasure of presenting to the senate the credentials of the Hon. John M. Thayer and Hon. T. W. Tipton, elected senators from the new state of Nebraska. I ask that their credentials be read and that they be sworn.
   THE PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE: The senators from Nebraska will now come forward and be qualified.
   The senators elect were conducted to the desk of the president pro tempore by Mr. Sumner and Mr. Chandler, and the oaths prescribed by law having been administered to Mr. Thayer and Mr. Tipton, they took their seats in the Senate.
   MR. TRUMBULL: I offer for adoption the following resolution:
   Resolved, That the senate proceed to ascertain the classes in which the senators from the state of Nebraska shall be inserted in conformity with the resolution of the 14th of May, 1789, and as the constitution requires, and that the secretary put into the ballot box three papers of equal size, numbered 1, 2, 3. Each of the senators from Nebraska shall draw out one paper. The paper numbered 1, if drawn, shall entitle the senator to be placed in the class of senators whose terms of service will expire the 3rd day of March, 1869; the paper numbered 2, if drawn, shall entitle the senator to be placed in the class of senators whose terms of service will expire the 3rd day of March, 1871; and the paper numbered 3, if drawn, shall entitle the senator to be placed in the class of senators whose term,; of service expire the 3d day of March, 1873.
   The resolution was adopted.
   Three papers were accordingly put into the ballot box; the senators advanced to the secretary's desk and each drew one paper. Mr. Thayer drew the paper numbered 2, and was placed in the class of senators whose terms will expire March 3d, 1871.
   Mr. Tipton drew the paper numbered 1, and was placed in the class of senators whose terms will expire March 3d, 1869.


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

213

   Now that I am a member of the senate, and propose some of my reminiscences for the amusement of the old, and instruction for the young, I shall adopt the pronoun "I," for directness and precision.
   And I here pause upon the threshold and contemplate our surroundings.
   I find Massachusetts represented by Charles Sumner and Henry Wilson. The former well read in the law, polished in letters, enjoying a world-famed acquaintance, and distinguished as the champion of slave emancipation, The latter, the John the Baptist of the toiling masses and adorning the shoemaker's bench with the senator's commission. While men could admire Sumner for his persistency and acquirements, they could love Wilson for his success and nobility of soul.
   As chairman of the committee on foreign relations Sumner could not be equaled, and the great success of the military committee during the war of the rebellion was a feather in the cap of Henry Wilson. To the roll-call of Ohio responded Sherman and Wade, the former to direct the finance legislation, with an experience dating back to years in the house before his accession to the senate. "Old Ben Wade" seemed retiring from business, since there were no bombs to be cast into the slave-holders' camps, nor demands to be made for "rifles for two." With Trumbull, of Illinois, to preside over the judiciary committee, having as his associates Edmunds, Conkling, Hendricks, and Reverdy Johnson, the legal department approximated perfection.
   To the standard of Kentucky rallied James Guthrie and Garret Davis; the first-named seventy-five years of age, a flat-boat trader to New Orleans, a college student, a lawyer, fifteen years a Kentucky legislator and railroad president, and secretary of the treasury for President Pierce. Mr. Davis was in his sixty-sixth year; a Kentucky gentleman of the old school, pure in life, the soul of honor, a worshiper of Henry Clay and the peculiar institution for the African's good and the safety of the Anglo-Saxon. If a stranger in the gallery asked an Indianian to point out the greatest man in the senate, the reply would be, if from a democrat, "Toni Hendricks, of course"; while the republican


214

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

retorted, "When you muster your war governors we enter Oliver P. Morton." Rhode Island was represented by William Sprague and Henry B. Anthony; the former a governor at 30 years of age, a senator at 32, and subsequently known as the husband of Miss Kate Chase.
   The newer states were represented by comparatively new men, including reconstructed Tennessee. Among them Nye of Nevada was the general champion, the amusing orator, the bishop in Biblical quotations, and amidst the clinking of glasses, the festive inspirer. But as my intention is not to furnish a biography of the senate, I must pass over many of the fifty-four senators, equally worthy of mention, for during the war the states were admonished to place only on guard "the tried and the true."
   Never was a body of men better acquainted with a system of legislation, for under their scrutiny and moulding influences the legal superstructure had arisen.
   The war just ended had demanded a new currency and a system of revenue, and "war legislation" and constitutional modifications, and centralization of power and the fostering of the dominant political party by congressional enactments. Of the fifty-four senators seven had been elected as democrats and forty-seven as republicans; but of the latter many had been before the war democrats on the subjects of tariffs, and the construction of the constitution, and others had been whigs, agreeing with them as to the true doctrines of state rights. It was evident, therefore, that as soon as the government should be prepared to return to a peace basis again, unless the return was unanimously conceded, some republican methods would be repudiated and old cherished doctrines revived and made prominent. This defection had already commenced, and Dixon of Connecticut, Norton of Minnesota, and Doolittle of Wisconsin, were frequently joined with the opposition.
   But the most conspicuous opponent of radical republicanism, during the fortieth congress and subsequently, was Andrew Johnson, president of the United States. Mr. Johnson had been a lifelong democrat, a devoted union man, of a very combative


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

215

nature, and of most uncompromising individuality. In his youth he had never gone to school, and yet he acquired a fair English education. At seventeen years of age we find him a tailor by occupation; at twenty the Mayor of Greenville, Tenn.; at twenty-seven in the legislature of the State, and at thirty-three in the State senate. He was in congress ten years, beginning in 1843, and twice elected governor prior to 1857 in which year he was elected to the United States senate.
   Amidst the fury of the rebellion he left the senate to become military governor of his state, and received the nomination for vice-president in 1864. Mr. Lincoln had been assassinated April 14, 1865, and Mr. Johnson sworn into office on the 15th of the same mouth, only six days from the date of General Lee's surrender to General Grant.
   On the 26th of May, 1865, the last army of the confederacy having surrendered, and congress not being in session, Mr. Johnson began the work of reconstructing the rebel states, according to what was known as (his) "My Policy"; and which gave ex-rebels an opportunity of controlling completely the legal white element and freemen. Congress claimed the power over the whole territory subdued by war, and stood ready to comply with the 4th article of the constitution which declares that "The United States shall guarantee to every state in this Union a republican form of government."
   When, therefore that body assembled in the next session, the struggle began in earnest between the president and congress. On the second of March, 1867, an act was passed for the "reorganization of civil government in the ten rebel states," and another to "govern the tenure of civil office," both of which were promptly vetoed by the president, and as promptly passed over the veto. Thus stood the question on the day of our admission to the senate.
   As General Thayer had made an honorable record in the army and had experience in Indian affairs, it was very proper that he should be assigned to duty on the military and Indian affairs committees, while he also secured an assignment to that of patents.


216

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

SENATOR T. W. TIPTON.

1867-1875.

   Thomas W. Tipton was born upon a farm, near Cadiz, Harrison County, Ohio, August 5th, 1817. His father, Rev. William Tipton, was, during fifty years, minister of the M. E. Church. His parents were pioneers to Ohio, from Huntington County, Pennsylvania. He attended common school during winter seasons, more or less interrupted by farm work until seventeen years of age. Subsequent to his eighteenth year he spent one year in a select school in Waynesburgh, Pa., two years in Allegheny College at Meadsville, and two years in Madison College at Uniontown, Fayette County, Pa., and graduated in September, 1840, delivering the valedictory.
   Before graduation, as a representative of a college society, he utterly refused to appear in a joint debate, unless the faculty would allow him to argue against the "utility and policy" of the established devotion to the "dead languages," in the usual course of study. In this he displayed that trait of character, "the courage of his convictions," which stamped his personality during life and led him to change church relations and political associations in accordance with increased experience and investigation.
   Leaving college and returning to Ohio for a time, he engaged in teaching and reading law, being admitted to the bar in 1844.

CAREER IN POLITICS.

   Though a Whig, he was not able to vote for Gen. Harrison in 1840, having lost his residence in Ohio, while a student in Pennsylvania. ln 1844 he delivered fifty speeches for Henry Clay; in 1848 seventy-five for Gen. Taylor; in 1852, resigned a clerkship in the General Land Office in Washington, D. C., and gave four months to the campaign for Gen. Scott; in 1856 ad-


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

217

vocated Gen. Fremont as the first Republican candidate; in 1860, being in the Territory of Nebraska, could not vote for Mr. Lincoln, nor yet in 1864; in 1868 voted for General Grant; in 1872 for Horace Greeley, and canvassed extensively in the states of Nebraska and North Carolina; in 1876 canvassed in New York and Indiana for Mr. Tilden, and in 1880 in Illinois for Gen. Hancock, and in the same year was candidate for Governor of Nebraska and in 1884 worked and voted for Grover Cleveland.
   In 1845 Mr. Tipton, then 28 years of age, was elected to the Ohio House of Representatives. In 1860 was a member of the territorial council of Nebraska, which answered to the state Senate. In 1866 was elected to the United States Senate by the legislature of Nebraska and re-elected in 1869. In 1885 was commissioned Receiver of the United States Land Office at Bloomington, Nebraska.
   From the above it appears that he cast his presidential votes for three Whig, two Republican, and four Democratic candidates, Mr. Greeley being an independent Republican endorsed by the Democratic party.
   During his connection with the General Land Office in 1850, an opportunity for self-assertion and vindication drew from the young subordinate an emphatic refusal to answer questions relative to the conduct of a fellow-clerk who had fallen under the displeasure of the Honorable Secretary of Interior.

   Hon. Secy. of Interior -- DEAR SIR: Before I could answer your interrogatories I would have to sink the dignity of the man in the subserviency of the slave. Respectfully,

T. W. TIPTON.

CHURCH RELATION.

   At a time when slavery was making its last desperate stand against freedom in the territories, and blood was freely flowing in Kansas, he made an effort to lay aside his political armor and enter the M. E. pulpit. Being then in his 38th year, a public speaker of much experience, allowing no man to think or act in his stead, he soon found what an utter failure he must become


218

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

in attempting to submit to the surveillance of presiding elders, or in approving the manipulating strategy of the episcopacy in ministerial assignments.
   Soon, therefore, when called on to explain the mode of administration over his charge, and requested to be silent on the current topic of the times, his answer to the former question was: "My official members do as they please and I sustain them, and I do as I please and they sustain me." And to the latter: "I could not promise that to my father in his shroud." To a congregation he said: "While I occupy this desk you will have a free preacher, and all my words shall be free speech, and when you can no longer endure it, you may install a slave in my stead, and substitute for the Bible the Books of Mormon or Koran of Mohammed."
   While between him and his people there was the most perfect accord, he deemed it prudent to decline orders, and requested the Conference to make up the record, "Discontinued at his own request," and at once adopted the democracy of the Congregational church government.
   Coming to Nebraska in 1858, and elected president of Brownville College, an institution on paper, he organized a Congregational society of sixteen members, out of new and old school Presbyterians, Baptists, Methodists and Congregationalists, which was dissolved by mutual consent when the war of 1861-4 unsettled residences on the border. Eligible to a chaplaincy, he entered the 1st Nebraska Infantry in 1861 and was mustered out of Veteran Cavalry in 1865, and on the same day was appointed United States Assessor of Internal Revenue by President Johnson.
   During the war he was often in charge of subsistence and transportation for loyal refugees within the Union lines, and of applications for military emancipation of slaves.
   On the 13th of February, 1864, at Batesville, Arkansas, Mr. Tipton addressed the Free State Convention ordered by Mr. Lincoln.
   Chaplain Tipton was mustered out of service in July, 1865,


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

219

and on the same day commissioned by President Johnson as Assessor of Internal Revenue for Nebraska. He championed the cause of immediate state organization in the political campaigns that followed, and when the state constitution was adopted and the legislature met in special session on July 4, 1866, he and Gen. John M. Thayer were made the nominees of the republican party for the two United States senatorships. The journal of the joint session held on July 11, 1866, shows that a motion to proceed to election of U. S. senator for South Platte having carried, the first ballot resulted: T. W. Tipton, 29 votes; J. Sterling Morton, 21 votes. A motion prevailing to proceed to election of U. S. senator for North Platte, the first ballot resulted: John M. Thayer, 29 votes; Andrew J. Poppleton, 21 votes. So Nebraska came into the Union with two republican United States senators.

PEABODY MEDAL.

   On the second day of the senate session, the following March, before the organization of the senate was completed, Mr. Sumner presented resolution No. 1, "Tendering the thanks of congress to George Peabody, with a gold medal, for having donated large sums of money to states and corporations for educational purposes." During the day he called it up and asked its immediate passage, which was objected to because it had not been to a committee, and there was no evidence before the senate on which the case was founded.
   On the fourth day of the session Mr. Sumner delivered a speech, highly eulogistic of the donor, who had been in Massachusetts, lived in Baltimore and made most of his immense fortune by banking in London. In this he was followed by Johnson of Maryland, one of the ablest democrats of the nation.
   Mr. Tipton was well aware that an opinion obtained, that a new senator should "sit at the feet of Gamaliel" during a probation and not dare to dissent from the great leaders on the ordinary questions; but in the case before the body he saw plainly a tendency to discriminate between private citizens, and to be-


220

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

stow honors and medals where wealth was able to purchase, and he further believed that no jurisdiction should be taken by congress over any subject that was not national; and that the money from the treasury should never be taken and bestowed as gifts upon favorites. Up to this time he had not yet voted, and much as he desired to observe a modest silence, and acquire a knowledge of rules and precedents before appearing before his superiors in parliamentary knowledge and legislative experience, yet he could not consent to cast a silent vote and submit to an unfair criticism. Besides, Nebraska had not yet spoken in that august presence, and it was of the first moment that her representative should not place her in a false position.

NEBRASKA'S FIRST SPEECH.

   His impromptu speech was as follows:

   MR. TIPTON: It is not astonishing, Mr. President, that I should be solicitous in regard to the manner in which I should cast my first vote in this body. I acknowledge that solicitude on this occasion, and regret exceedingly that I feel impelled to say anything on this question at this time. Before I could vote for this resolution I should desire to understand most emphatically the position that was occupied by the donor during the time of our recent struggle national existence. I am inclined, however, because of the source whence this resolution comes, to infer that all was right in that behalf; but I ask for no enlightenment on that point, because I am against the adoption of this resolution not on account of any consultation with any member of this body, but from principle.
   If I need any justification for my course on this occasion I desire it to be understood that, if I am the representative of any body on the floor of this senate, I am the representative of an humble constituency; with such a constituency on the frontier I have been and shall hereafter be identified; and when I know positively that I have constituents of as pure intentions in behalf of education and science and art as the grantor of this charity can be, and when I remember that some of them have done all that men could do in a private capacity, and when I see this gentleman making a munificent grant in a private capacity, I can not consent to shower on him the thanks and honors of the senate when I am not able to vote to the humblest of my


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

221

constituency who have done equally well, having done what they were able to do; and he has done no more.
   I hope now that on that subject I am understood, and will be understood hereafter in all my future actions as a member of this body. So far as the munificence of this grant, as regards the amount is concerned, I concede it. Other wealthy men of our country have granted by thousands and tens of thousands, for educational purposes; and they have received the thanks of the corporations, and the thanks of states, and they will receive them again. If this grant had been for educational purposes in Nebraska I should not have come for a national endorsement for the grantor, but should have secured that from the recipients of the charity, from my own constituency in Nebraska.
*   *   *   *   *   *

   If this were a national gift, if it stood on the basis of the Smithsonian grant, I would, as a matter of course, be willing to vote the thanks of congress of the United States; but it stands on no national position whatever and therefore that can not be claimed for it. In making this grant the donor, I understand, declared that he did it as a duty. If it is done as a Christian charity, as a Christian duty, he has his reward hereafter, and the consciousness of it here, and I am not disposed to doubt the ability of the Almighty to reward him to the utmost, and I do not suppose it is necessary for me to help the Deity out by granting a gold medal here. I prefer to leave him to his golden reward hereafter. I think he also says he regards it as a privilege to make this gift. Sir, it is a privilege, a privilege that few men will ever have; and the benefits of the privilege are great--distinction among men here, honor after death, for having granted so much for so great a charity.
   With this view of the question, impelled to it from a sense of duty, I cannot and will not make any distinction between the giver of a dollar and the giver of a thousand, and the giver of a million, when each in his sphere and in his capacity has done all that it was possible for him to do in behalf of education, science and general literature.

   On the final passage of the resolution the only votes in the negative were those of Grimes of Iowa and Tipton of Nebraska.

DEMOCRATIC UTTERANCE.

   Eight days from this date Mr. Tipton showed his willingness to stand by a democratic utterance and as promptly to retort a republican sarcasm, while he forecast radical sentiments intensi-


222

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

fied by four years with the army. The question before the senate was, whether more than a majority of the registered votes should be required to readmit a rebel state.

   MR. TIPTON: I have this to say: that the more this question is discussed the more I feel an interest in it, and the senator from Indiana (Mr. Hendricks) spoke the democratic truth when he said that such a rule as that now proposed, so subversive of the principles of democracy, would have kept a recent state out of the Union. That is true. You have never required it of the people of a territory. I represent a people who were permitted to come here, in case they could show a majority in favor of a state organization, and I will not therefore under any circumstances cast a vote by which some other constituency shall not come here by a single one of a majority. This is my democracy on a question of this kind.

   The conclusion of his remarks was as follows:

   Sir, we went to a loyal minority when we went with our arms in our hands to release them; and I propose to go to that loyal minority now, and a majority perhaps that would be willing to give as good attention to the poor remarks I should make as many of the senators here just at this present speaking.
   I go to that loyal minority, and I say a majority of them, so help me God, shall control the destiny of the south, and the destiny of the rebels of the south. For four years we have done without the representatives of disloyalty in this chamber; for four years more we can do without the disloyal in organizing states at the south; and loyal white men and loyal black men will come to our aid in this matter.
   I am not willing that the disloyal, by any classification or any mathematical calculation shall be permitted to stay at home and assist in defeating the loyal men of the north. This may be called spurious morality and philanthropy. I would suggest for the benefit of the senator from the state of New York (Mr. Conkling) that when he goes on a peddling mission with his "fine-toothed combs" he may find as much necessity for them in the purlieus of the city of New York as in the humblest freedman's cabin in the whole state of South Carolina.
CAUCUS RULE.

   The senate convened on the 3rd of July, 1867, having adjourned from March 30, in order to supervise the actions of the


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

223

president on the question of reconstruction of the states lately in rebellion. At that time an Indian war was desolating western Kansas and Nebraska, and a portion of the senators had as much denunciation for our frontier settlers as for the murderous savages. But others than senators from the West admitted the importance of the crisis. Still there was an indisposition to act in our behalf, and a resolution was passed in caucus and offered in open senate to exclude action on all subjects at that session, excepting reconstruction. The omnipotence of the caucus was asserted by one senator as follows: "No senator can be superior to the decrees of caucus," and it was charged that men of honor must abide its decisions. To this replied Mr. Tipton:

   Before the vote is taken, at whatever expense to myself in the opinion of the senate, I have a word to say. The senator from Maine asserts, as I understand, that he is warned in regard to future actions with men who differ in regard to what is honorable on a question of this kind. I was a member of that caucus. When my colleague in that caucus suggested that if we passed the resolution we might be precluded, possibly, from doing something, if an opportunity should offer, in behalf of our suffering frontier citizens and those of Kansas, I, taking that view of the question, from that moment voted against the resolution.
   After voting against it in the caucus, I came into the senate. The senator from Kansas notifies the senate by a proclamation from the governor that the glorious little state calls upon her citizens, who cannot give ample protection to her own citizens, to go and help the government protect the United States property--the Union Pacific Railroad. Seeing the conditions of things there in a more precarious light than I did see them day before yesterday in the caucuses, I felt that under these circumstances I would not be true to my constituents and my state were I to allow the behests of any body, any organization, to cause me now to step aside from Kansas and her troubles, and Nebraska and her troubles, and say we will not entertain a proposition in your behalf. I should not be a man of honor if I permitted myself to act thus, and I say no senator here could claim that he acted honorably if he had gone back upon his constituency under these circumstances. I am very free to hear from any senator that he disapproves of my course, and says I am not bound by as high a principle


224

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

of honor as ever animated his breast, when with that additional notification from Kansas, I say here, neither caucus, nor senator, nor power, shall prevent me from introducing a measure, if necessary, for my own state. Charged distinctly with that, I part hands with any man, and all men, willingly.

   His colleague, Gen. Thayer, being on the Indian committee, was amply able to present the question of relief with zeal and intelligence, and favored a removal of the predatory savages beyond the limits of Union Pacific Railroads; and the organization of frontier settlers into a military force for local protection. Exasperated with the sentiments of the East and insulted with the assumptions of the caucus, Mr. Tipton was in no humor to mince matters, and hence found the outside limit of parliamentary etiquette in the subjoined remarks:

PREMIUM ON SCALPS.
   I have all faith in the secretary of war, and all faith in the chairman of the military committee of the senate, as to their good and kind intentions toward us on the frontier; and yet I do not believe that our present system of warfare is worth anything; and I mean more than is coached in that word "anything" when I utter it. It has done nothing for us on the frontier. For the last three years our people have been slaughtered every day, and this day, as it is now about the hour of half past one o'clock, undoubtedly has had its victims also.
   If I could wield the legislative power of this Nation to-day, I would so remodel the whole system, that I would make it a high crime for a regular army officer to cross the Missouri River for the next twelve months; I would offer a premium for savage scalps; I would enlist the men of the frontier; I would appoint as commanders of that army the men who understand Indian warfare, if it is to be understood at all.
   Our present system is inefficient. We never have successfully combatted with savages. We may worry them out by the power of this Nation; but we want an experiment at relief of some kind. And now leaving the balance that I ought not to say, for probably I should not have said what I have said in this latitude,--it is true, however,--I yield to my colleague.


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

225

REPLY TO SENATOR WILSON.

   Immediately the chairman of the military committee entered his protest against the sentiments of the senator from Nebraska, as in his opinion equally as far from Christian civilization as savage warfare. To which Mr. Tipton replied:

   The senator from Massachusetts understands me in this: that so far as tribes will be bound by treaty stipulations, we will act in the utmost fairness with them. The murderous tribes now plundering and desolating our frontier will be bound by no treaty. They have no faith to keep with us. They cannot be intimidated but by an exhibition of power. You cannot speak to them about the inhumanities of life. You cannot utter to them one single word of Christian civilization. All is powerless but an exhibition of power on the part of the government. Until you can cause them to fear and tremble in your presence; until they understand that you will deal with them just as they are dealing with you, you cannot save the lives of your women and children; and when it comes to that I would authorize war upon these savages that cannot be approached. I would save the lives of our Christian women. God help the country, and the reputation of the country, when a senator is to stand in his place here and dare not be permitted to talk of the massacres, and worse than massacres of the women of his constituency, and not also to talk about premiums on savage Indian scalps.
   I trust I understand the amenities of Christian society. I trust I understand something of Christian civilization. Why, certainly the light of Massachusetts has visited us long since upon that subject, and we are trying to practice puritanism as best we may be able to apply it to practice even in the very far West.
   Our people are in their cabins today; they are in their dirt-covered hovels today, and they are looking from their loop-holes for some relief, and therefore I stand here proudly to vindicate the doctrine, with regard to those Indians who can hold no faith with you-premiums, anything, paid in gold for those savage scalps.

   Such was the condition of affairs in the West in June, 1867, that General Sherman said, writing from Fort McPherson, Neb., to the secretary of war: "Fifty hostile Indians will checkmate three thousand soldiers." He said in an order: "We must act
   16


226

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

with vindictive earnestness against the Sioux, even to their extermination." The result in congress was a commission ordered to attempt a treaty.
   In the foregoing and a few other casual utterances counter to popular prejudice, and discarding mere conciliatory policy, appeared the senator from Nebraska, upon the skirmish line of parliamentary discussion, at the end of the first session of the 40th Congress.
   This session was the most peculiar of any that had ever preceded it, inasmuch as it kept in perpetual session, by an adjournment from time to time. Meeting on March 4th, 1867, and on the 30th of the same month adjourning until the 3rd of July and on the 20th of July adjourning to the 21st of November and continuing to December 2nd, being the first day of the second session. The object being that no harm should come to the republic during a recess, from aggressive acts of President Johnson.

PRESIDENT JOHNSON'S MODE OF RECONSTRUCTION.

   The basis on which he attempted to reorganize the rebel states provided that the persons taking part therein should have taken an oath of allegiance to the United States, according to his amnesty proclamation, and were qualified as voters according to the laws of the state before secession. And the convention or legislature should have power to "prescribe qualifications of electors and the eligibility of persons to hold office."
   This left it possible for the rebels then in power to perpetuate themselves in office, through the formality of a convention and a new election, unless they were ruled out by the 14th amendment to the Constitution of the United States. Once in power again, the Freedmen were at their mercy, as to the elective franchise. As a result of this mode of reconstruction, senators and representatives for Congress were mostly taken from a class of men who had held office under the Confederacy; from those also who had abandoned seats in the Congress of the United States to levy war against the government, while legislative and state officers


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

227

were mostly taken from the ranks of the army of the Confederacy.
   Persons of that class could not take the test oath, and hence could not have been admitted at Washington, even if the reconstructed states were approved. Having appointed governors at his pleasure, and settled the amounts of their salaries, and having declared peace and recognized states, he went so far as to assign Agricultural College scrip to North Carolina, assuming functions belonging to Congress. And yet the President had held very different views on rebels coming to the front in reconstruction. At Nashville, Tennessee, June 9, 1864, he said:

   I say that traitors should take a back seat in the work of reconstruction. If there be but 5,000 men in Tennessee loyal to the constitution, these true and faithful men should control the work of reorganization and reformation, exclusively. If a state is to be nursed until it again gets strength it must be nursed by its friends, and not smothered by its enemies.

   So marked had been his radicalism, fears were entertained, on his accession to power, that he would be impracticably severe, and being from the South, the men lately in arms had much to fear; but when he began to champion a course so much more to their taste than the plan of Congress, their spirits revived.

REBEL CONFESSION.

   On this question Senator Tipton used the following language in a speech delivered in Congress in February, 1868:

   I do not wish to be uncharitable, and am therefore inclined to pause just here, and dwell upon the fact that, if left alone, the penitent rebel and the unrepentant would neither of them be asking or desiring to-day the privilege of voting. On the day of surrender they would have said: "We entered the war against you, determined to destroy the American Union; we hated the idea of nationality; we cherished the fancy of state sovereignty; we adored the institution of slavery as a system of power and wealth, a concomitant of aristocracy, and the proper cornerstone of civil government. The appeal of our Revolutionary fathers in behalf of universal freedom were all discarded; and when men of the North were exiled from the South,


228

NEBRASKA STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY.

or warned not to enter it with hopes of hospitality, if they came cherishing the doctrines of Jefferson on slavery, we yielded a hearty approval. We turned our pulpits against the doctrine of universal brotherhood; we expurgated our literature; we put our orators and poets under bonds to be true to our prejudices and desires; and during all these four years of war by assassination, by conscription, by starvation in prison pens and dungeons, we have bankrupted earth for expedients of destruction. Have mercy upon us and allow us to retire to obscurity. If life and property are granted, we will ever remember your great and astounding magnanimity; but with all our national mistakes, and national sins, do not expect us to aid, and cherish, and build up through the ballot box, the late object of our vengeance. With the blood of the avenging angel on our door-posts, we cannot, in less than. a generation, forget this calamity. Perhaps we have loved our states too blindly; but without doubt we have bated the government of the Union with a perfect hatred. You have administered your government without us; your ways are not as ours; besides we had sworn each to the other to 'die in the last ditch,' rather than live again under the hated stars and stripes; and now your principles are to triumph, which we do not understand. But if they redeem our desolate land; if they build up our ruined cities; if they bring commerce to our silent harbors; if they again erect the school and college; our children may some day yield that obedience which we refused. If there are any among us who can embrace your constitution; if any who can spend their time and means in sustaining your Union party by swearing truthfully that they never gave aid or comfort to the enemies of the country, in your discretion let them do so."
   That these men so lately in arms should be placed on probation until congress had approved of loyal state governments has been advocated by Johnson himself. He has said, "My judgment is that he (the rebel) should be subjected to a severe ordeal before he is restored to citizenship."
   A fellow who takes the oath merely to save his property, and denies the validity of the oath, is a perjured man and not to be trusted. Before these repenting rebels can be trusted let them bring forth the fruits of repentance.
CONGRESSIONAL PLAN OF RECONSTRUCTION.

   The congressional plan provided for military supervision during the process of reconstruction, and for a constitutional con-


NEBRASKA IN THE U. S. SENATE.

229

vention of delegates, elected by the "male citizens 21 years old and upward of whatever race, color or previous condition"; and the constitution to affirm the same of the future voters, and the legislature to adopt the 14th amendment to the United States constitution. This plan discarded alike the state organizations that were overthrown, as well as those established under the Confederacy, allowing the military power to use them for provisional purposes only. The oath of office required the voter to swear that he had not been disfranchised for participation in my rebellion or civil war against the United States.
   Mr. Tipton's fidelity to the congressional mode had been amply tested before his appearance as a senator, since he had been a federal office-holder, and learning that he would not be recommended to the senate for confirmation unless he adopted the policy of the president, he declined to do so, preferring to go out of office rather than give up his political convictions.

HAVEN OF NATIONAL SAFETY.

   A few days before the House of Representatives appeared before the bar of the Senate with articles of impeachment against the President, Mr. Tipton occupied the Senate with a long and carefully prepared speech, covering the whole ground of debate, concluding as follows:

   Mr. President: The only path of duty for us to travel is that marked out by the light of Christian civilization. We are pledged by the spirit of our institutions: by Pilgrim vows and Pilgrim faith, by interpositions of Providence from the hour of the Mayflower peril to the fall of treason's banner, to do, by our legislation, all and everything demanded by the strictest rules of Heaven's justice. When we attempted to evade a settlement of the slavery question after the American Revolution of 1776, we gradually commenced to illustrate the proposition, "Whom the gods would destroy, they first make mad." When we denied its inherent criminality and turned the Bible precepts aside, and with the emblems of bread and wine enticed Christ's humble poor to the table of communion in order that the soul driver might, with greater accuracy, cast the lariat over the head of his property, we were invoking Heaven's vengeance and mortgaging the blood of a whole generation. When


Prior page
TOC
Next page

© 2001 for the NEGenWeb Project by Pam Rietsch, Ted & Carole Miller